If I Was Kyle Singler…

by Duke Blue Devils

First of all, I could never be Kyle Singler. If you’ve ever seen my jump shot, you’d know what I’m talking about. I also could never imagine being in his shoes right now, forced to make a life-changing decision…to go or not to go?

Having said that, I’m certainly going to try to be Kyle Singler…for at least one post.

Would I go pro or would I come back for one more year of college?

For me, the answer is…I’d go, although I wouldn’t say it is an easy answer.

First, I’ve accomplished what I’ve wanted to accomplish in college. I won a national championship. I did it playing my best ball, winning MVP of the Final Four. I went head-to-head against other pro prospects (West Virginia’s Butler and Butler’s Hayward) and I was the better player on the court each time.

Sure I could get better as a player with another year of college. Just look how I did this past year. I struggled early at a new position, but by the end of the season, I was one of the most productive players in the nation. I earned All-ACC First team.

However, even if I improve my ball-handling skills some and get my three-pt shooting above 40%, the one big strike against me, my athleticism, will still be a concern next year. As great as Coach Kryzewski is, he’s never going to make me run faster or jump higher. What’s the old saying, “you can’t teach speed?” It’s true.

If I turned pro this year (which seems to be the popular thing to do), I’m projected to go anywhere between 17-30. Of course there is a big difference it terms of cash betwen #17 and #30. At #17, I’m going to average about 1.2-million over three years. If I’m #30, I’m looking at just under 900k per season.

In reality though, I would be shocked if I fell into the 20′s, which would land me about 1.1-million per for three years. More importantly, that’s just one more year less before I can become a free agent.

Now I know what some will say. If I come back, get better, I’ll be drafted higher, thus make more money. But how true is that? Let’s assume there is no lockout and the rookie salary structure is the same. Where would I end up?

Next year’s draft will again have some one-and-done’s and lots of early entries. Even with improvement, I don’t think I’m going to crack the top-10. Think about it, in 2011, teams will possible get to choose between Harrison Barnes, Enes Kanter, Kyrie Irving, Brandon Knight, Perry Jones, Jared Sullinger and Alex Burks, just to name a few.

But just for fun, let’s pretend that I can improve my game and be the 10th pick in the draft next year.  My average salary will be 1.9-million. That’s a good amount change in my pocket, but that again assumes I can get into the top-10 and that assumes there will be no lockout.

The fact is, for it to be financially beneficial for me, I need to probably be be drafted no worse than #14, since I would make the same amount of money (in the same time frame).

Of course, this isn’t just about money. My family out in Oregon has done fine for themselves, so I don’t have to worry about hardships. 

The thing is, going pro now can only get me better. First, the benefit of getting drafted later, instead of the lottery is that I won’t be asked to save some sinking ship of a franchise. I’ll end up on a playoff team. Sure I won’t start and I won’t get a ton of playing time, but I will get to practice day in and day out with some of the world’s best basetball players.

Like I said, that’s what I would do if I was Kyle Singler and those are my reasons why…but again, I’m not him.

For all we know, he might like college life. Plus, if he comes back, the Blue Devils would be the preseason No 1 team and he would have a chance to not only repeat as a champion, but earn All-American honors and maybe even get his name lifted up into the Cameron Indoor rafters. Those are three very important things.

Time will tell how important.

Topics: 2010 NBA Draft, Kyle Singler

Comments
  • Philip

    Great analysis. Also, as my mom likes to say, “There’s nothing better than graduating with a Duke diploma.”

  • Rob

    Smart mom. Mine said, “Go to jail one more time, I’m not bailing you out next time!”

  • Nathan Stallion

    I agree. Even more, go pro because Duke needs Singler more than Singler needs Duke. I’m guessing that with workouts against other SF prospects, scouts will see and remember why this guys was rated #4 overall in the class of 2007. His first two years were good, but he sacrificed his pro status by playing out of position. This guy would be a pro already if he had played SF his freshman year. Singler is a stud and he plays harder than any other prospect, this attribute will move him up in the draft. I be he doesn’t fall below 15 this year. Go singler.

  • Marty Pifer

    One more year of experience in anything never hurts anyone, expecially when they will be in the center of it all. Kyle always looks like he is having a blast playing college ball. I cannot see him sitting on the bench of some pro team and enjoying watching the games day in and day out. Wow how did players 10 years ago do it by staying in school 4 years and becoming better players, people and friends? That must have been tough. As you get older you will realize money ain’t everything, but memories, relationships and development are. I just see too many guys leaving early missing out on so much because someone tells them money is the answer to everything. Kyle has always worked hard and like Shane Battier did from year 3 to 4, I see Kyle improving next year under the guidance of his coaches at Duke. That is irreplaceable !!

  • JJ

    Haha…. you guys are hilarious.

  • Howard

    There are a lot of things to love about Kyle. His attitude, his work ethic, his great jump shot, his can-do spirit; I can go on and on. I think Kyle’s game has evolved in his three years at Duke and the versatility in his game has always been evident, and even that part of his game has grown. His athleticism is what it is, and I think it’s good enough to be a good player at the next level. Does he have some stuff to improve on? Yes, but that’s good because you don’t want him to have maxed out in College. I believe in the NBA he’ll improve his ball handling, and with nothing but basketball to focus on he’ll find ways to score around the basket without dunking over talleror more athletic players. He has big hands and a high basketball IQ, so he’ll be fine. I think it’s curious though that Kyle outplayed Ewbanks and Hayward, but he, so far, is projected behind them; that’s the frustrating part about the NBA. Kyle is in a win win situation, I’d love for him to stay, but it’s probably best that he moves on to the league and works on his degree off campus. Great job Kyle.

  • atlduke68

    From a purely business point of view, I agree with your analysis. I haven’t looked deeply at the numbers, but I expect Kyle would go higher next year even if his stock didn’t rise, since there seems to be a bigger exodus of underclassmen than usual this year due to the threat of a lockout. But as you point out, the additional $ probably don’t justify the risks of his stock falling, the lockout, getting hurt, …

    However, Kyle may be one of these rare kids who is able to look beyond the $ and consider his legacy. How does he want to be remembered 20 years, 30 years, 50 years from now? If he comes back next year and leads Duke to a strong finish, he has the opportunity to be included w/ Duke’s all-time greats: Banks, Dawkins, Hurley, Laetner, Hill, Singler… I also expect that Kyle knows he’d really enjoy one more year at Duke playing in the best basketball atmosphere in the country alongside other great players and without the academic pressures of a full class load. And what has he given up for that opportunity? 1 year of a 10-12 year NBA career.

    It’s a very tough call. He’ll get my full support whatever he chooses…

  • Anonymous

    The right choice for him is to turn pro. The momentum may not ever be higher after coming off of a FF MOP award. However, I would like more analysis and consideration regarding the prospects in this year’s draft versus next year. It seems like the potential of the lock-out in the NBA has opened the flood gates for anyone and everyone who is considering turning pro. To me this says two things: One, the competition in next year’s NCAA’s will be down thus making Duke’s repeat chances better. How much more valuable would Singler be having won back-to-back FF MOP’s and National Championships? Second, there will be fewer talented prospects going pro next year, making the probability higher that he would be picked higher. Thoughts?

  • Chris

    Why do you keep saying Singler is going pro. I am sure he will test but best case I have seen is one of the last picks in the first round to early or mid second round. I love the guy and he is a great college player, just not what all pro teams covet (although I think he is better than Chase Budinger and he played well this year). In the end I feel like all Coach K can guarantee him is a second round pick with a chance at the First. Look at who has declared, Hayward (Butler), Johnson (Cuse), Ebanks (WVU), the two foreigners Jay Veesly and Danatas guy, Turner (Ohio St), Xavier Henry (Kansas), Jordan Crawford (Xavier), Aminu (Wake), Ekpe Udoh (Baylor), Pat Patterson of Kentucky, all these guys can fill similar needs for teams and play the some combination of the 2,3, and 4 and I just dont see Singler being taken ahead of any of these guys. He is kind of stuck at the 3 and wont be able to play the 4 in the pros. And you know athleticism is the major factor and Hayward has him there. I think it is more likely Hayward goes in the lottery than Singler staying in the draft. Besides Mason is our top rated prospect at 19 on Chad Fords list on ESPN. This years class is much more loaded than next years class will be and he will be taken higher next year than this year. Maybe 2 titles potential national player of the year, he will still be the same guy in the pros eyes but he will never get this next year of college ball back. Singler is not an idiot and will be back to see his number up on the rafters and hopefully will be the next national player of the year to join the other Duke greats.

  • Rob

    I keep saying it because everything points to that. Don’t get me wrong, I want him back and I hope he comes back. There are plenty of reasons to come back. However-

    - He’s said in the past if he was going to be a 1st rd pick, he’d probably go.
    - His parents have stated this week, that Singler is being told that he will go anywhere between the 18-30th pick.
    - Just about every mock draft site has him going in the back of the first round.
    - Kyle has said that if he goes pro, there is no looking back. If he declares, he’s taking an agent.

    If winning another title, winning player of the year and getting his name up in the rafters was important to him, I just think he would have already decided to stay.

    I think he clearly wants to go, but he needs to make sure it is the right decision, thus he’s waiting for the NBA season to end, waiting for everyone else to declare and figuring out where he might go in the draft. If he’s not happy with it, he’ll come back.

    However, I’m trying not to think like a fan and I’m trying to think like a coach. What advice would I give him (knowing what I know, which is less than Coach K knows).

    Coaches have to be honest with kids these days, even if it hurts their program in the short term. If recruits don’t think the coach will have their best interest in mind, then they won’t go to those schools. Think about it, Calipari doesn’t get top talent because he wins championships.

  • Anonymous

    You make great points…I wish you hadn’t and hope Singler doesn’t read this but you really do. On the other hand, Kyle can get better and more athletic in college. Look at Redick in the pros, he’s been able to increase his first step speed. If Kyle starts improving his ball handling, foot speed, and strength now he has a better chance of playing more minutes sooner in his career. He could also work on his post moves to become more multi faceted, a la Melo.

    I am biased of course but I really hate seeing Duke rookies sit on the bench. I would rather they work on developing an all-around game all four years then make the jump to the Pros. To me they are better equppied for a longer, more productive career vs quick upfront money that ends after 3-4 years.

    It would also become mandatory for Coach K to put Kyle in positions to develop more of his skills. Something he should have done with Shelden while he was there.

  • atlduke68

    I just hope he gets J.J. on the phone and asks him if he’d trade his senior year at Duke to join the NBA a year earlier. I think Kyle’s rookie year in “the league” will likely be a lot like J.J.’s, while he has a good opportunity to create something even more special his senior year than J.J…. The $ of the NBA will be there for him. Unlike Brand, Avery, and others before, the Singlers live a very comfortable life and aren’t in great need of an NBA salary. He has only one chance to win back-to-back NCs, earn first team all-American honors or even NPOY, and claim his spot in the rafters among the Duke greats.

  • Chris

    I am not speaking strictly as a fan and I agree with the facts that Singler is riding high right now and if he declares he will not look back, I am just saying that no one is gonna take him above 26 because there are too many guys that have declared that are 2-3 3s or 3-4 tweeners that teams are gonna take before they take Kyle. Coach K has told him that but yes he will more than likely end up with one of the last 2 or 3 picks of the first round, However we have seen it before and if there is not a need on one of those teams in the back of the draft he can say goodbye to the guaranteed contract. I say it is smarter to come back because next years class is gonna be pretty weak and he has the chance to slide into the top 20 and might be able to earn some PT on a pretty solid team that is working its way to contending with the NBA elites. IF he gets taken in the first round this year he will be riding pine for the Lakers, Magic, Cavs, or someone like that for the life of his 3-4 year rookie contract. I am not saying he wont declare, I am just saying he should be realistic look at who else has declared and then think that 18-30 is a more realistic 24-36

  • Brandon

    The suspense is killin me. Anyone know around when he will announce his decision?